Ok guys. I have had 9mm's for a looong time. My dad has suggested that I upgrade to a 45 semiauto. I am seriously considering this and plan to go "looking/buying" on Thursday Would like your opinions. Should I just stick with my 9mm's or move up to the 45. IF I get the 45 it will most likely be a smaller framed model such as the Taurus milpro.
Opinions please! (poll)
1 - 20 of 63 Posts
Joined
·
11,589 Posts
If you want to get a .45 then by all means, do so. But you aren't poorly armed with a 9mm...both will get the job done if you do your part.
Joined
·
562 Posts
Absolutely agree!
Honestly, no. I have never even laid eyes on one. Isnt it close to a 357?
Joined
·
2,200 Posts
I believe it is closer to a .41 Mag, but I will defer to those in the know. You may want to try it out since you are making a move anyhow.
Joined
·
2,256 Posts
Why not have both ?:thumsup I've been a 9mm man forever, but after picking up a Kimber 1911, I'm torn. I rotate between the 2.
Joined
·
6,454 Posts
There is TONS of info, studies and statistics listed here (FCC) on both calibers.
I have an Springfield XD45 (.45) that holds fourteen. I also have a Kel Tec PF9 (9 mm). I love the XD but you can't beat a gun you can put in your pocket. I feel safe with the 9 mm (what ever that means?), I just wish it held fourteen instead of eight.
What I have gathered (I'm no pro to say the least) is that shot placement is very important with handguns.
DED says "it will do its part if we do ours" or something like that?
Good luck! Don't think you can go wrong.
Franklin:ak
I have an Springfield XD45 (.45) that holds fourteen. I also have a Kel Tec PF9 (9 mm). I love the XD but you can't beat a gun you can put in your pocket. I feel safe with the 9 mm (what ever that means?), I just wish it held fourteen instead of eight.
What I have gathered (I'm no pro to say the least) is that shot placement is very important with handguns.
DED says "it will do its part if we do ours" or something like that?
Good luck! Don't think you can go wrong.
Franklin:ak
Joined
·
186 Posts
Honestly, you should own the firearm that you can consistently hit center mass with, regardless of whether it is 9MM or 45 ACP.
They will both do the job.
However......
The first gun I ever shot was my dad's Colt 1911, and I have to tell you I have been hard pressed to find a better gun than the 1911, although the Hi-Power comes close...
If you do decide to go 45, take a good look at Kimber before you buy anything. You may just fall in love...
They will both do the job.
However......
The first gun I ever shot was my dad's Colt 1911, and I have to tell you I have been hard pressed to find a better gun than the 1911, although the Hi-Power comes close...
If you do decide to go 45, take a good look at Kimber before you buy anything. You may just fall in love...
Attachments
Joined
·
186 Posts
ummmm......
I think you just did.:rolf
I think you just did.:rolf
Joined
·
10,556 Posts
Nope, I just " hinted " a bit ...
Is it just me or does that 45 have hair growing on it?I won't say how I voted ....
![]()
I vote for one of each..:thumsup
Joined
·
2,709 Posts
What do your want it for? To carry? HD gun? fun gun? I think everyone should own a .45 of some sort. Just cause you buy it doesn't mean you have to use it for defense.
Joined
·
13,998 Posts
Just remember, a smaller framed .45 packs a punch but may also have a kick!
I like 45s but would rather have a full sized one than a compact. Even a 9 in a very compact frame can be uncomfortable for some and effect your accuracy. For some, that is not a problem and they shoot them very well and even enjoy the punch of it. Me, I am made of softer stuff!
The 9 is Fine and I'll just keep mine!:drinks
I like 45s but would rather have a full sized one than a compact. Even a 9 in a very compact frame can be uncomfortable for some and effect your accuracy. For some, that is not a problem and they shoot them very well and even enjoy the punch of it. Me, I am made of softer stuff!
The 9 is Fine and I'll just keep mine!:drinks
Joined
·
11,164 Posts
Bingo!
Joined
·
6,454 Posts
Soft stuff, that's funny. Your little PF9will remind you that you just pulled the trigger and you and your soft hands actually chose and bought that snappy gun little gun.Just remember, a smaller framed .45 packs a punch but may also have a kick!
I like 45s but would rather have a full sized one than a compact. Even a 9 in a very compact frame can be uncomfortable for some and effect your accuracy. For some, that is not a problem and they shoot them very well and even enjoy the punch of it. Me, I am made of softer stuff!
The 9 is Fine and I'll just keep mine!:drinks
:rolf1 - 20 of 63 Posts
