Florida Concealed Carry banner
1 - 20 of 32 Posts

· Registered
Joined
·
58,517 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 · (Edited)
In this thread http://floridaconcealedcarry.com/Fo...-muzzle-pressed-against-your-back-from-behind we discussed what others would do with a gun put in their back during a robbery.

This thread will discuss the "Draw against the drop" [ few have ever seen this performed in any training environ let alone been privy to the mechanics and even fewer who have been allowed to practice this skill ].

There are only 4 people authorized to train others in the skill tested in the real world [ myself being one of the four ] and advanced as a viable option by the originator. He knows it works in the real world.

The main requirements to perform this successfully and should not be attempted unless these criteria/circumstances are met.
1. Being able to use both hands simultaneously to perform different tasks
2. A draw stroke that is well practiced and takes 1 second or less to get your first shots into the perp
3. Being capable of reaching the offending weapon without moving anything but an outstretched arm.

Someone has brought a deadly weapon to bear on your person in close enough proximity to meet one of the requirements/criteria above.

We could attempt a disarm of the offending weapon as has been discussed often enough on this forum in some manner [ there are several variations on this theme that may work depending on our skills level in this area ], but there's also this option of the "draw against the drop" which has worked in the real world as well. It's not for the faint of heart and requires superior gun handling/draw speed but there are people who have draw speed in sufficient quantity out there who could use this option in lieu of attempting a disarm.

The following narrative will take into account the perp is holding the weapon in his/her right hand. Simply mirror the narrative for a left handed perp.

With your left hand, you move/push the offending weapon off body from the outside so that the perps arm is now cross body as well as your own [ the perps hand is moved to near or a 10 O clock body position as if he were reaching to get into the front left slash pocket of their pants.

Your left hand has gained [ and maintains ] brief control of the wrist/hand of the perps with your hand ending up near a 2 O clock position as if you were starting to cross body gain access to your front right pocket.

At the same time as the above, you access your firearm from it's holster on the right side and place either the barrel/slide or your wrist/start of your forearm on your left forearm about mid way between your wrist and elbow and fire into the perp, at the same time slightly turning/twisting your upper body to the right which helps keep control of their weapon by extending your left arm and locking the elbow [ thus becoming stronger at thwarting their possible attempt to turn/move their weapon back onto your person .

By either rotating the barrel/slide across your left forearm, shots can be zippered up from about belly height to upper chest immediately. Remember that the above will all take place in one second, perhaps a few thousandths more. If you don't/can't draw your firearm and get the first shot off in that time or less, the risk increases exponentially that it's not going to be successful.

It may be hard to visualize the above, and one caveat warning should be mentioned-- Your firearm will be muzzling your own non dominant forearm briefly to get the gun or your wrist/lower forearm in proper position.

It's a viable option that's worked in the real world IF you have the speed of draw, can use both arms to do different tasks simultaneously and the offending weapon is close enough to reach without moving.

Sounds complicated in narrative and may be problematic to visualize the above, but it doesn't take any time to demo it in training and it's certainly another option for those who are strength challenged vs their opponent and would be better served by being guncentric in this instance as long as they have their speed of draw in sufficient quantity and enough "ugly" [ attitude ] to call on to make the move and end the threat.

I imagine this thread has the potential to get real interesting in the responses. Some members have seen this demonstrated in the past in my courses, and would be a perfect example of why airsofts are great for this type of skills practice.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
4,660 Posts
brownie, in the example given of a police officer should I assume a typical "open carry" and then factor more potential time needed for concealed draw?
 

· Registered
Joined
·
6,250 Posts
Action beats reaction

Brownie,

I know you are familiar with my background (when I was a full time firearm instructor part of it!) so I will keep it simple for all, who are not.

Most of my classes (for 22 years) Security, Revolver carriers, ATM/Armored Vehicles.

Each class were shown this exercise, after they were shown how to give up! Howe to give up? Man 3 yards away points shotgun at you, demands liability, Cash, whatever.

Without moving body, just arms/hands, slowly, raise hands, palms out, await commands.

Much against the company's wishes, we do not advocate handing over the liability! They said.

With a Remington 870 12 gage, no barrel, now stand till the tube touched the body (my body!) "When you see me move, press the trigger" It is not possible to press the trigger, causing the CLICK before the muzzle had cleared the body (I know no muzzle!) but you know what I mean.

So not as a class as such, but the class knew it was suicide at 3 yards, but the start of a chance from touch distance.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
58,517 Posts
Discussion Starter · #4 ·
brownie, in the example given of a police officer should I assume a typical "open carry" and then factor more potential time needed for concealed draw?
Yes, he was carrying openly in his duty holster. His draw stroke open carried to first shot was around .45 seconds when we trained together and that after some 20 years later after the incident he'd encountered. It was touch and go to first shot when we shot side by side, clearly he had the speed at over 60 years of age, and I was 54-55 at the time.

The faster you can draw to first shot, the better but one shouldn't attempt this with a 1.25-1.50 draw stroke from concealed. My own concealed draw stroke to first shot from under a T shirt right now hovers at the .88 to .95 seconds with the occasional draw to first COM shot as high as 1.12 seconds presently at 60 years of age [ which should enlighten those who believe age has to slow you down in some regards ].
 

· Registered
Joined
·
58,517 Posts
Discussion Starter · #5 ·
Scouse,

Action will usually beat reaction times for most people. Mindset to act in your own defense without hesitation, the confidence you have the ability to succeed [ training and practice ], and no physical disabilities that may unnecessarily hinder your response are key to staying above ground in these types of deadly situations.

:thumsup
 

· Registered
Joined
·
58,517 Posts
Discussion Starter · #7 ·
I did not read the thread but is pooping your pants one of the techniques taught?
No, that function does nothing to get the muzzle off your person nor would it resolve the threat you are facing :grin
 

· Registered
Joined
·
21,796 Posts
ive tried practicing this with my airsoft and my own idpa tpe targets...obviously not as effective as with a real person but i dont know anyone in my neighborhood who would be willing to take the beating to practice this live while we poke holes in each other with airsofts...

i have also practiced rushing my aggressor and tying up the gun arm while i draw and place multiples into the sternum from retention while i drive the aggressor backwards off balance....

i dont know how this would work in a real situation but i thought it would be valuable to have the skill i the event of a scuffle...
 

· Banned
Joined
·
11,156 Posts
This is actually a very effective maneuver. A variant has been taught in law enforcement circles for the last 50 years. All that is required for the technique to be successful is to move and hold the offending handgun off line until you can draw, aim and fire your own handgun. Blinding speed is not necessary for this to work, but a smooth draw is required. Tom Cruise demonstrates this type of technique in Collateral [though he fails to properly control first subject's gun and engages them in reverse order].
 

· Registered
Joined
·
58,517 Posts
Discussion Starter · #12 ·
Cruise sweeps the perps gun arm in a similar fashion, but doesn't control [ read, retain contact with the arm ] the perps gun arm nor lays his gun and or wrist on his own firearm. The CD scene would not be the time to use the Draw against the Drop [ DATD ]. The perp wasn't close enough to trap the perps forearm correctly nor would it be used against two assailants.

Draw stroke speed can't be blindingly fast without being extremely smooth. In Fof with this skill, you'd better be at the times I mentioned in the original post or you're going to find yourself getting shot. You may also shoot the perp, but that won't do you much good when you were too slow to draw and fire and you've been perforated or stabbed, etc.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
4,525 Posts
Thanks for the clarification, Brownie, I see what you mean.
Guess I'll stick with my, grab my chest, stammer "Heart Attack" and collapse. Hopefully I'll be Able to slightly turn away and draw in the confusion as I'm going down.
It looks good on paper!
 

· Banned
Joined
·
11,156 Posts
Cruise sweeps the perps gun arm in a similar fashion, but doesn't control [ read, retain contact with the arm ] the perps gun arm nor lays his gun and or wrist on his own firearm. The CD scene would not be the time to use the Draw against the Drop [ DATD ]. The perp wasn't close enough to trap the perps forearm correctly nor would it be used against two assailants.

Draw stroke speed can't be blindingly fast without being extremely smooth. In Fof with this skill, you'd better be at the times I mentioned in the original post or you're going to find yourself getting shot. You may also shoot the perp, but that won't do you much good when you were too slow to draw and fire and you've been perforated or stabbed, etc.
OK, I'll bite. If you are defending against a high presentation [the opponent's firearm is above the mid-point of your chest] why would you have to shoot OVER your blocking arm? Wouldn't it make more sense to shoot UNDER that arm and into your opponent? And if this technique can't be used against more than one opponent, as Cruise did, it seems inferior to the one presented in the movie[ granted, Cruise failed to control the first gunman's hand, which he easily could have done, and engaged the man whose gun he had under control rather than the man whose gun was not under control, first]. It seems that the DATD technique that you are presenting is needlessly complicated. Is there any video of it being performed?

The trick to this technique being effective is maintaining control of the gunman's hand or weapon until you can draw and engage him with your handgun.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
130 Posts
Brownie, What would be the best way to adapt that if I'm a southpaw? Step to the outside and get my right arm under/outside and pushing up/across the body of a right handed opponent and fire the first shot from the hip into their side. Or push their arm to the outside, and firing COM? One has my weak hand changing direction, the other has me pushing against their locked elbow.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
58,517 Posts
Discussion Starter · #17 · (Edited)
OK, I'll bite. If you are defending against a high presentation [the opponent's firearm is above the mid-point of your chest] why would you have to shoot OVER your blocking arm? Wouldn't it make more sense to shoot UNDER that arm and into your opponent? And if this technique can't be used against more than one opponent, as Cruise did, it seems inferior to the one presented in the movie[ granted, Cruise failed to control the first gunman's hand, which he easily could have done, and engaged the man whose gun he had under control rather than the man whose gun was not under control, first]. It seems that the DATD technique that you are presenting is needlessly complicated. Is there any video of it being performed?

The trick to this technique being effective is maintaining control of the gunman's hand or weapon until you can draw and engage him with your handgun.
If you are defending against a high presentation [the opponent's firearm is above the mid-point of your chest] why would you have to shoot OVER your blocking arm?

You wouldn't, you'd use a different technique. I mentioned "The CD scene would not be the time to use the Draw against the Drop [ DATD ]. The perp wasn't close enough to trap the perps forearm correctly" I didn't bring up the CD Cruise scene in comparing the DATD to what he did in the movie. There is no commonality between the two whatsoever.

if this technique can't be used against more than one opponent, as Cruise did, it seems inferior to the one presented in the movie

Hence the statement, "The CD scene would not be the time to use the Draw against the Drop [ DATD ]". Another skill/technique would be used that would afford better chances of success. The DATD is a technique/skill like any other, it is effective under certain circumstances and not in others. I'd not use 1/2 hip from 50 yrds, but that doesn't mean it's not effective at 3-4 yrds. No one skill will be correct for all situations, this one is no different in that regard Mac.

It seems that the DATD technique that you are presenting is needlessly complicated.

If by complicated you mean you have to use both hands simultaneously, I suppose there are some who can't chew gun and walk at the same time, but I mentioned that as a requirement in the original post. Not only is it not complicated, it's not needlessly complicated. If it were that complicated it wouldn't work even under the right conditions.

Is there any video of it being performed?

Not that I'm aware of.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
58,517 Posts
Discussion Starter · #18 ·
Brownie, What would be the best way to adapt that if I'm a southpaw? Step to the outside and get my right arm under/outside and pushing up/across the body of a right handed opponent and fire the first shot from the hip into their side. Or push their arm to the outside, and firing COM? One has my weak hand changing direction, the other has me pushing against their locked elbow.
This skill would not work well at all for a southpaw with their own firearm on the same side as the perps. No more than I'd use this skill against a left handed perp because I'm right handed and wear my edc on the same side of a southpaw. There are other options other than this skill available and as I responded to Mac, it works when certain circumstances are presented as threats that need to be addressed.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
6,250 Posts
As Tom Cruise is portraying a heartless killer, would not taking cover behind the Cab, at the passenger side door, and shooting the the one on the right in the back, twice, be more in keeping with the character?

The non briefcase carrying one first? Of course.

Natural reaction of #2, would be to drop the briefcase, as he turned towards the threat. The laptop was in the briefcase, would not want to damage it with bullets.

First shot would be like target practice, upper center back, no risk, Mr. Cruise should have been on the right side of the Cab, for first shot. Distance, 12m?

Would have given him time to put his ear plugs in. What? Not as sexy. No words? Sorry, I think he would have seen it as just part of the job.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
386 Posts
It didn't hurt that BG #2 seemed to have great difficulty trying to get his weapon out of his waistband, particularly since he appeared to have his hand on it as they walked toward Cruise. On the one hand, it's Hollywood and the script dictates all. On the other hand, it is possible the surprise at having his bud with the obvious hands-down advantage summarily taken out could have stressed him to the point of terminal fumbling.
 
1 - 20 of 32 Posts
Top